I will help you out and tell you that "Bumfluff," "Roller Derby," and "Hammer House" are not the title for this year.
Title guesses so far:
Aftermath of the Zombie Pumpkins
Band of the Zombie Pumpkins
Battle of the Zombie Pumpkins
Blood of the Zombie Pumpkins
Children of the Zombie Pumpkins
Civilization of the Zombie Pumpkins
Cult of the Zombie Pumpkins
Cursed Return of the Zombie Pumpkins
Day of the Zombie Pumpkins
Diary of the Zombie Pumpkins
Festival of the Zombie Pumpkins
Ghost of the Zombie Pumpkins
Harvest of the Zombie Pumpkins
Haunting of the Zombie Pumpkins
Hell of the Zombie Pumpkins
Infection of the Zombie Pumpkins
Infestation of the Zombie Pumpkins
Land of the Zombie Pumpkins
Legend of the Zombie Pumpkins
Legion of the Zombie Pumpkins
Life of the Zombie Pumpkins
March of the Zombie Pumpkins
Martyr of the Zombie Pumpkins
Massacre of the Zombie Pumpkins
Nightmare of the Zombie Pumpkins
Plague of the Zombie Pumpkins
Planet of the Zombie Pumpkins
Reanimation of the Zombie Pumpkins
Rebirth of the Zombie Pumpkins
Reign of the Zombie Pumpkins
Returm of the Zombie Pumpkins
Rise of the Zombie Pumpkins
Scream of the Zombie Pumpkins
Season of the Zombie Pumpkins
Shaun of the Zombie Pumpkins
Slaughter of the Zombie Pumpkins
Spawn of the Zombie Pumpkins
Survival of the Zombie Pumpkins
Terror of the Zombie Pumpkins
Tomb of the Zombie Pumpkins
Torture of the Zombie Pumpkins
Vengeance of the Zombie Pumpkins
War of the Zombie Pumpkins
Wrath of the Zombie Pumpkins
The winner will get a free Pro Pumpkin Carving Tool ($20 value), AND... their membership will be upgraded to the next level above where it stands at the time of the contest's end.
In other words, if you're a...
non-member > would be upgraded to Bare Bones plan ($2)
already a Bare Bones plan ($2) > would be upgraded to Break Ground plan ($5)
already a Break Ground plan ($5) > would be upgraded to Whole Harvest plan ($10)
already a Whole Harvest plan ($10) > would be upgraded to Monster Harvest ($20)
already a Monster Harvest ($20) > I'll send another free item when I send the carving tool prize
As a reminder, the first person to have posted in the correct title in this thread is the winner, and each person gets only 3 guesses. First 3 guesses count, can't change your mind.